I'm sitting in the lounge at the Land's End Hotel, at the end of the spit in Homer, which is 'the end of the road,' the location of the Kachemak Bay Writers' Conference. I'm registered, have my tote bag and name tag, and ended up signed up in the first slot for the open mike to read some poetry! Excited, nervous, anticipatory.
The Naturopath reiterated yesterday that I need to eat more, and specifically more protein, and that a lot of the residual symptoms I'm experiencing will improve if I do. So, my minor epiphany (helped, I'm sure, by the fact that I've been writing (poetry) this week, which always makes life feel better): if eating more will make me feel better, isn't it worth a try?!?! There is such a strong equation between raw-foodism and asceticism, and it's so easy for me to slip back into 'scarcity mode,' but really, what's not to like about feeling better? I don't want to go into too much detail on this because I want to get on to the book review, but another helpful comment from the Naturopath was that the nausea that I frequently experience after eating, and that encourages me to always eat less, is very possibly a 'habitual' response from my body, who has become used to associating food with ill feeling. So, if I can actively work against the nausea, maybe the food can actually do some good!
OK - without further ado, the first of two book reviews that I want to share this week.
On David Mitchell's Cloud Atlas
This 529-page novel is a little hard to get into, but it blew me away! And I wouldn't call myself an easy grader as a reader. It's the best novel by some way that I've read in a long while, and I've been reading some really good ones just recently.
Like other Postmodern novelists such as Haruki Murakami and David Foster Wallace, Mitchell's style is intensely virtuosic, multifarious, speaking in many tongues, vocalizing many voices, accents, idioms. Like those others, he exploits strange and tenuous connections as focalizing points that link different parts of the story together, and makes bizarre and abrupt changes of scene with a mere spandrel of connection between them.
But unlike them, he writes as if there is a deep, underlying message, as if he cares about communicating that message, as if it really matters to him. I often come away from Postmodern novels dazzled by the brilliance, awed by the virtuosity, but thinking 'So what? What happened and what was the point?' (and I do understand that often that is precisely the point.) Reading Cloud Atlas, I experienced all the dazzle and the awe, but also a deep impression that I was receiving something significant that would stay with me a long time, almost to the level of something like Ursula LeGuin's The Dispossessed.
I mentioned that it's a little hard to get into. This is because of the ring-composition or 'Russian Doll' structure of the composition. The novel consists of six novellas, each set in vastly different places, times and genres, from the 19th century South Seas to a post-apocalyptic Hawaii via 1930's Belgium, the West Coast of the USA in the 1970's, present-day England and near-future Korea. Genres are journal, letters, thriller, film/memoir, interview, oral storytelling. The first five novellas segue into one another without warning (the first gives way to the second in the middle of a sentence, for example) and we then get the second half of each of these in reverse order after the central novella. (Might be interesting to go back and read each novella beginning to end.) Each novella is referred to in its successor, so that each of them is a real world within itself that is later reduced to a work of fiction: fascinating self-referentiality. The 'Russian Doll' structure is also frequently referenced in subliminal moments, as well as the number six as the dominant feature in the weave.
This all means that Mitchell - and we - are dealing with six different sets of characters, six different genres, six different scenarios, six different dialects/language uses, even. Where there are moments of stereotyping and pastiche of course, I find myself able to forgive it readily: with such sharp contrasts at work, it's sometimes good to write it large. And whilst the poignant beauty of expression and the enormity of the deeper meaning sometimes brought tears to my eyes, I also cried with laughter at the masterfully overdone tale of woe at the hands of British Rail in the fourth novella.
Some small concerns: there is free use of quotations in languages other than English, and the whole of the sixth novella is written in a created post-apocalyptic version of Hawaiian pidgin, with apostrophes everywhere for elided and omitted sounds: very busy on the page, which makes it hard to read and maybe hard for someone who isn't a linguist to follow. I'll put my cards on the table: I love all of this: for me, it's an enrichment, it makes me engage more deeply with the text. But, I'm a linguist and multilingual enough to be able to understand the quotations in other European languages at least (I don't remember any Korean-language quotations, but if the characters' names had deeper meanings that would have gone over my head). And I know that that particular element of the virtuosity, the bewilderingly adept code-switching and the quotations, might be alienating for some.
I guess he has an audience in mind and that's who he targets. It's definitely me. You too?
I am so grateful to have read this, because of the double inspiration I received from it. First, I'm inspired by the beauty and virtuosity of the writing. Second, and perhaps more important, I'm inspired by the depth of the message conveyed through the storytelling: the care for life and its unfoldings. It gives me the hope that I may be able to do something like that with my writings too.
Anyone else read this? I recommend it so highly. For something completely different, I devoured his next novel, 'Black Swan Green,' in a single evening. It is totally different, being told through one single perspective, that of a 13-year old boy in small-town west England. But delightfully enough, several characters from Cloud Atlas are encountered in the course of the story, at very different stages of their lives from those in which they appear in it.
Here are some links I have found online about David Mitchell: