Thursday, March 3, 2011

Tapping and Feeling Empowered; PUFA-Experiment Update

Feeling Good: Thanks, Tapping World Summit!
We are such moving targets: we adjust one thing and something else changes too. Sometimes change spreads like a stain, from the focal point outward; other times, it's more like a domino effect, and everything changes in a cascade.
A snapshot only catches a glimpse of our perpetual motion.
I am so excited by having the feeling of being able to make things better. I'm so excited that I've woken up the past couple days feeling really energized and confident! I have been working on the Tapping, having listened along this past week or so, and am amazed at how it has been affecting my energy and general outlook. With any method of self-help and self-improvement--or anything novel, for that matter, I worry about the trajectory where an initial burst of enthusiasm then gradually peters out and moves into disenchantment. However, the Tapping is having such an immediate and positive effect, internalizing the Law of Attraction into my physical meridians, that I'm finding myself motivated to continue with it. They suggest committing to 40 days of Tapping post-summit, clearing one blockage each day. Now, I'm thinking that many of my 'blockages' will take more than a single day to clear, but I'll take the empowerment of group energy and the optimism of commitment!
Any suggestions, shared stories, ideas for further reading would be much appreciated.

Further thoughts on PUFAs (and how to avoid/reduce them) and an Update on My Experiment
Self-Experimentation
Speaking of being moving targets, and of the impossibility of changing one thing without changing others... Of course I haven't been 'perfect,' haven't completely eliminated all PUFAs, not even all omega-6's. But I have dramatically reduced them in my diet the last month or two, and on the few occasions that there's been something more omega-6-heavy around, like that peanut-butter-mousse brownie (yes, my fault!) I've added back some flax or chia into my morning smoothies to balance it out.
Here's a post by Dr Weil that Mindy shared in a recent comment that explains in straightforward terms why it's so important to keep the omega-3 to -6 ratio from getting overly high to the -6, to rebalance if you have something high in the -6.

Well, a couple of observations on this. I hadn't realized until I put flax/chia back in my smoothies that the post-breakfast nausea I'd had for ages had gone away. It came back when I put them back in! Whaddaya know? And I don't think it was a case of higher overall fat content: I think I'd upped the coconut oil in my smoothies to compensate. So that's an unexpected downside of flax or chia for me (I hadn't noticed any correlation with nausea at times other than breakfast, though).

Otherwise, I haven't noticed any instant alarm signals like memory loss, neurons not firing, intense depression, or any of the EFA deficiency classic signs. One the other hand, I haven't noticed that my metabolism is roaring quick all of a sudden without the metabolism-dragging PUFAs (although my digestion transit seems to have improved, as I mentioned earlier, but that seemed to be more to do with increasing starch consumption).

One negative thing that I have noticed, or more accurately, that Phil has noticed, is that my skin is not as clear and smooth as it had been since I started coconut oil and a generally higher-fat diet. It seems that my back is broken out and that generally my skin is a little rougher. Again, I don't know whether to ascribe this to absence of PUFAs, to reduced fat intake overall, to increased starch, or to my excursions into cacao and more sugar than normal for me (mostly by way of fruit).

For other reasons, which I'll discuss more soon, I'm nixing the cacao and sugar excursions and suspect, just from how my body works, that I should replace them with more fat, i.e. coconut, in my diet. Hopefully that will smooth my skin out, but if it takes flax and chia seeds and a few nuts to make that happen, it would be some interesting data for sure!

PUFAs and How to Avoid Them
Unless you're of the 80-10-10 persuasion (as I was for years) and avoid all fats like the plague, it might sound like a pretty tall order to be a mostly raw-foodie who eats good amounts of fat and to avoid all heavy PUFA sources. In fact, it's really pretty easy. When I started out, I wasn't even eating avocado or olive oil on my salads for a bit, and was still enjoying satisfying and delicious salads as a staple. (Lately, perhaps for sanity's sake, and partly because my ND specifically asked me to eat avocados, I've eased up on that restriction: both olive oil and avocado have much more Monounsaturated fat (or MUFA) than they do PUFA.)

This is a 'slaw that is pretty much what you can see: napa cabbage, purple cabbage, carrots, sprouts. The dressing was made of appropriate spices, apple cider vinegar and coconut oil! Kind of Asian-tasting and really good and refreshing.

Since macadamia nuts have virtually no PUFAs in them, you can team them up with coconut to make all kinds of creamy dressings and dips. By the way, here's another instance of a case where the 'cooked' version of something might be healthier than the raw. At the moment, I feel better about eating real black beans than a raw mock refried beans dip made mostly of sunflower seeds (although it's true that legumes contain more omega-6 than omega-3 also, like most seeds of any kind, flax and chia being the magic exceptions, legumes have far less of either than nuts and seeds do). Ditto for nut-based hummuses.

For the wiggle room, since I'm not crying off them altogether and forever, there are ways to reduce overall PUFA content in your creation. I think the best long term strategy is to use mostly coconut and macadamia (sure makes me miss Hawaii--why are mac nuts so expensive when the farmers there can't sell their crops?) and otherwise use flax and chia so that the PUFA ratio favors the omega-3's.

But for the excursion times, I already showed in my peanut-butter-mousse-brownie recipe how easy it was to reduce the PUFAs by using mostly peanut flour instead of peanut butter.
Thankfully for us, cashews and filberts are relatively low in overall PUFA (around 2g per ounce), so they'll work for the odd cheesecake and crust...(though I love a mac/coco crust).

Another trick: remember those Congo Bars I made all the way back before Christmas (wow, have I been playing with reduced PUFA that long??
Well, the base involves a whole bunch of walnuts and pecans (i.e. a boatload of PUFAs), that you pulse first and then add a bunch of other ingredients. I processed them a little far, and the cold ambient temperature and the warmth of the processor provoked the nuts to release their oils, and they separated from my dough. Rather than try to mix it back in, I poured it off!
It was a slow process: you can see the oil still pooling at the parchment paper under the batter to the left of the pic. I probably got about a half cup of oil from those two cups of nuts! So that was a half cup of PUFA that no one had to eat (although it may end up on Phil's popcorn one day)!

Conclusion: I feel good about continuing my moderate exclusion (as opposed to exclusive exclusion!) of PUFAs. I still think that the most important thing is to avoid much omega-6, however, and I wouldn't be shocked if long-term, flax and chia regained their status as staples in my diet. More changes coming soon!

What do you think about omega-6's? Do you think I'm over-thinking this whole thing or is it interesting? What's your latest great experiment on your body? (And what about that Tapping?)

9 comments:

  1. I have noticed that with some of the older folks in town (and Doug Graham) that have been low fat for awhile they skin is not as tight and is quite saggy. But it could be from a lot of sun exposure as well. It surprises me though because other raw foodists who have been in it long term have better skin.

    I try to have more Omega 3s than 6s, and making my own food helps with that. I have to say I worry less about the types of fats I eat than the types of veggies (due to thyroid) and types of grains. I seem to do well on most types of raw fats.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow, interesting that chia and flax seeds gave you nausea. I've eaten huge bowls of chia pudding, and Ani's pancakes made of nothing but flax seeds, coco oil and sweetener. Never had that particular problem.

    I have the seeds, but I enjoy flax oil (and hemp oil) as well. I've taken to squirting a small glug of flax oil in my green smoothies. I think the added fat makes them a bit more satisfying, and that way I make sure I get some good omegas early in the day. I also enjoy making salad dressings with flax oil and/or hemp oil. Both of these oils seem to go down really well for me. Good luck with your many experiments.

    ReplyDelete
  3. bitt--I've heard that correlation between low-fat and poor skin quality (especially with age) numerous times and I think there really is something there. My skin definitely improved hugely when I added in more fat. But my ND today suggested that my current skin issues are to do with something else entirely (PCOS), so I'll talk about that a bit in my next post.

    Very interesting perspective and balance, comparing vigilance around fats to vigilance around veggies and grains: that's really important to bear in mind too.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks, Mindy--I don't understand the nausea there either, and I'm pretty sure I've eaten chia puddings (not for breakfast but later in the day) without trouble too. Strange...

    Your squirt of flax/hemp oil sounds like a good addition to a smoothie--I like putting in coconut oil.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think your PUFA experimentation is interesting. At this stage in my eating I am not too worried about about the types of fats that I am eating as I haven't noticed any negative side effects from one type or another. But I like to read about your research.

    As for Tapping, I think I first learned about it in "Biology of Belief" by Bruce Lipton. I've tried it a couple of times out of curiosity, but didn't feel compelled to continue on a regular basis. I find that for me, more than anything, sunshine and exercise (preferably together) work wonders in clearing blockages and reminding me about what is important in life.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think you have "One Lovely Blog": http://cabinblendings.blogspot.com/ !

    ReplyDelete
  7. kt--that's good to read that you're not noticing anything particular good or bad from different fats.

    Thank you so much for mentioning Biology of Belief: that book's been on my radar for a while and I very much want to read it.

    Off to find out about One Lovely Blog!
    love
    Ela

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks for all the great info on your low-PUFA experiment. I'm casually cutting down on PUFA-rich oils (and vegetables oils in general, really) though not things like seeds, walnuts, or peanuts.

    Yesterday I read a couple articles from Jeff Novick, as well as a couple discussions on his FB page, and I was astounded at how many people are insisting that coconut oil's saturated fat is STILL terrible for you despite the lauric acid. It threw a mild kink in my coco-love, though I'm certainly not convinced of all this. I did read an article, though, supposedly refuting most of Bruce Fife's research...I still feel coconut oil is powerfully healthy, but this stuff did make my head spin a little. Any thoughts of your own on the Novick school of thought?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hey Amber,

    I definitely think it's more important to cut out veg oils than to cut out all nuts and seeds (although I think it's a good idea to 'buffer' the omega 6 in other nuts with flax and chia).

    I've read Jeff Novick's articles and taken in isolation, they do make sense. It can certainly make my head spin, because I'm not 'certain' about anything. There are also other people who say that it's 'wrong,' 'unnatural,' etc, to eat any kind of oil, because it's not a whole food. I subscribed to this myself for years.

    But at the moment, I have to say that despite the attractiveness of that idea, I stay with the coconut oil because I seem to have been doing so much better than before I ate it. If I still lived in HI and had massive access to whole coconuts, I don't think I'd need the oil. But up here, it's definitely a godsend. Essentially, since it's working for me, I just choose to put the Novick theory to the side.

    Is that any help to you at all?
    love
    Ela

    ReplyDelete

I greatly appreciate any and all comments, and endeavor to respond to each one individually. Until I have figured out a fully automated comment platform, I try to 'hand-deliver' responses to comments to your email address. If I don't know your email address, please check back here within two days for your response!