Thursday, April 19, 2012

Who's for Dinner? (HAWMC)

I think I'm funny with the title--last week, one of the topics I was teaching was how the brain processes linguistic ambiguity, and one of the sentences whose ambiguity my students had to explain was "Kids make healthy snacks." Lexical ambiguity three ways--can you see all three?


I love how my stream of consciousness on Simic yesterday segue'd both into the essay I had to write on Simic and into an aspect of this personal essay on which I've been working furiously the past month. I've been writing every spare minute since my last post! Even the harder prompts have been generative and helpful this month!


Yes, the HAWMC prompt for today is to imagine a dinner party to which we can invite five guests, yielding MFK Fisher's ideal party of six, I notice, including anyone, either living or dead. I agree that six is a good number for a dinner party--intimate enough to allow melding of ideas and sustain a single conversation rather than having people break off into little groups. But how on earth am I supposed to pick just five people from all of history? Additionally, am I to envision a dinner party based just on conversation, or am I to take into account food preferences too? Do I need to invite people who would be content to eat carrots with me, or do I plan an elaborate spread, none of which I'll eat, and spend the party bustling in and out of the kitchen like my grandmother does (did)?


Actually, I can make eating carrots seem fairly attractive, between this carrot cake...
 ...and these carrot brownie bites...
 ...and this carrot cream cake!
But anyway, who's for dinner? One of my first thoughts in response to this question was to recall a post from Lori a month back in which she and Amber and their partners met up in San Francisco. Since I used to live in the Bay Area too, and love both these ladies so much, from afar, at the time of reading all I could think of was that I wished I could have been there too. Add my Phil, and we'd have a party of six--we could all go to Cafe Gratitude or Millennium, if we left it in SF! I'd love to spirit Joanna down from Portland too. And definitely make sure Meredith joined us. That's the West coast...


If I stayed in the blogging world, there's several other ladies whom I haven't yet had the pleasure of meeting in person and with whom I'd love to spend a relaxed evening. Basically, everyone whose blog I read is someone I would like to know. I imagine a wonderful evening in NYC with Gena, Lori and Michelle, Shannonmarie, my dear friend Bitt, and perhaps we could spirit Lisa down from Toronto to join us too--if I'm in NYC, anything is possible! There's a lady in Boston I'd love to have join us there too.


For another spin, as part of the prompt, they also suggest including some possible reference to your health condition. Well, one of my health conditions isn't exactly conducive to dinner parties (!) Another of my 'conditions' is one shared by very many artists and poets, so perhaps I'll just give my imaginary dinner party with artistic ladies (funny that all my dinner parties are mostly ladies) from across the years. This will be a spiritual banquet of souls, because I have no idea how to devise a meal that would please palates from two thousand years ago and from the present day and from across the world, as clever as I am about "dishes dissolving difference." So, around that table I would have Sappho, and Sei Shonagon, and H.D., and Adrienne Rich, and Naomi Shihab Nye. There's one other person I would invite, if I could exceed the "five" stipulation, and that would be my great-great-grandmother Rachel of Basra. I don't even know her last name--I don't know my great-grandmother's maiden name, and they all changed their names when they moved to Israel anyway. This Rachel, for whom my mother and several of her cousins are named, never left Iraq. She died before the expulsion of the Jews in 1950. But I would love to get to know her, to give her the opportunity to know one of her descendants, as she was apparently a barefoot doctor. My mother's healer persona and my own fascination with herbs and remedy-concocting, as well as nutrition, probably comes from her. Naomi, she, and I (ha, sounds like "Naomi Shihab Nye!) could talk about peace in the Middle East. Myself aside (if I am alive), Naomi is the only living poet in that bunch, and she exemplifies the life-affirming, welcoming spirit that would cement the group. 


I would love--love--to be present for a meeting between Sappho and H.D., and to be able to participate in that conversation myself. Last month I wrote a huge essay about H.D., some of it about how she uses Sappho in her poetry as a bridge to enable expression of deeply personal material behind the mask of translation. If you know me at all, you'll understand why that interests me so. I'd love to see whether the Sappho that H.D. projects is the same Sappho who lived on Lesbos in the 600's BC, and how H.D. would respond to getting to know the real woman. And I'd love for all of us to meet with Sei Shonagon from Japan, with her medieval courtliness and her feminine strength. I'd love for Adrienne Rich and Sei Shonagon to talk about the role of women in the world. Gosh, wouldn't you love to be at that party?


Who would YOU invite to your dinner party?

13 comments:

  1. I love linguistic ambiguity, watching syntax trees sprout up in my head...

    I also love that you considered guests' food preferences when thinking about this list!

    I'm so honored and delighted I landed on both your and Lori's lists. As I told her, these dinner parties need to really happen in real life! If only. :) I'd attend both of your coastal soirees.

    As far as "historical persons" go, there are MANY that I'd like to go back and meet, but I've always said I'd like to sleep with Julius Caesar. I bet that man was a stallion. ;) Ooh, and/or e.e. cummings...ahh, the romance. Or why not both? :P

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Haha Amber, you in a threesome with cummings (whose name is pun-worthy in that regard too) and Caesar! I love this.
      Can't wait to meet you one day...
      love
      Ela

      Delete
  2. Ela, I love the way you swirl the concepts into a perfectly created pie decoration. Thank you for the invite. I gladly accept. You, of course, are definitely someone I'd have on my living list. Your delves into your roots brings up a question I've been asking the universe lately, and anyone who will listen. What makes us define ourselves culturally? To say I am half-Russian is only because my mother is Russian, again only because her parents were Russian. Only one was born in Russia but sometime before that, one family was German, the other French. My mother nor my grandmother was born in Russia. What does it all mean? I believe culture is much more than that. I am intrigued by the travels of your family and any cultural definitions you have. Great post, though!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Meredith, it's a fascinating question. I think the commenter on my post yesterday brought up some good points in this regard, in terms of where our pain comes from. I also think Americans have a tendency (sometimes annoying to folks from the old world) of defining themselves in terms of where their ancestors came from--trying to hang on to some sort of an identity to separate themselves from others. For people from Europe and the Middle East, it can be confusing two ways--first, most national boundaries have changed so much, so someone "German" might come from what is now Poland but also languages are spoken across national boundaries, so a Yiddish speaker might come from Romania or Russia or Germany or Poland; an Arabic speaker could be Christian or Jewish or Muslim or other, and could come from many countries in North Africa and the Middle East...and second, for people from the old world, being nationalist/partisan has been so divisive and caused so many wars, so that the possibility of coming to a new country like the US and gaining such a prestigious title as "American" might seem so tempting--leave all the old identities behind.

      I think my mum has some of that around being English--to her, it's a prestigious identity, with all the stigma of being Iraqi in a European-dominated Israeli culture, or of being Jewish in a non-Jew-dominated culture, removed.

      We should talk sometime!
      love
      Ela

      Delete
  3. I gladly accept this invite! And what a wonderful, provocative question. There are so many people I'd love to dine with from the blog world and my own past, but to be honest, I, like you, would probably want to resurrect some writers: Virginia Woolf, David Hume, John Donne, Adrienne Rich, Gloria Steinem, George Elliot, Charles Dickens. The list goes on. And from our own time, Tom McCarthy, Alice Munro, Mary Gaitskill, Amy Hempel, and of course, my own muse and hero, Marilynne Robinson.

    xoxo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Gena--I'd love to be present at a banquet where you chose the attendees--I concur with so many of the literary figures you mention, am intrigued by those of whom I'm ignorant.

      Marilynne Robinson is your muse? I'm an admirer too. And when Phil and I first got together, one of the first books he gave me to read was Gilead

      love
      Ela

      Delete
  4. I do hope one day to be with you and all of those lovely ladies in NYC. xoxo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Let's put the intention out to the universe!
      I'd love to meet you anywhere, though, you world traveler you!
      love
      Ela

      Delete
  5. I would love to come to your dinner party ... as long as we aren't dinner and the kids wouldn't be served up as the "healthy snacks." Ha ha. Crazy how these things can be read in different ways.

    Happy Friday! :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Happy Friday to you! Thanks for playing with the pun--we'd have lovely carrot-based goodies and lots of greens and would be the diners, not the dinner!
      love
      Ela

      Delete
  6. I would LOVE to have dinner with you too, how sweet of you to invite me to the virtual meal. I'd love some carrot anything to eat.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. One day, bitt--one day! We'll make it happen somehow!
      love
      Ela

      Delete

I greatly appreciate any and all comments, and endeavor to respond to each one individually. Until I have figured out a fully automated comment platform, I try to 'hand-deliver' responses to comments to your email address. If I don't know your email address, please check back here within two days for your response!